The Weber Spirit series has always been my go-to for reliable backyard grilling, and this year I finally got to cook on both the EP-425 and the E-425. At first glance these two four-burner workhorses look almost identical—sleek black finishes, stainless accents, and the same trademark Weber sturdiness. But after a month of back-to-back cooking sessions, I discovered a handful of details that could tip the decision for different grillers. Here’s everything I learned from real-world testing.
Key Difference Between Weber Spirit EP-425 vs E-425 Grill
The EP-425 is essentially the “premium” version of the E-425. It adds a built-in digital thermometer and upgraded stainless-steel side tables and control panel, giving it a slightly more upscale, tech-friendly feel. The E-425 skips the digital readout and uses a cast-aluminum control box but keeps the same burners, Boost Sear Zone, and Weber Works accessory compatibility. In short: same firepower, different finishing touches.
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
Quick Comparison Table: Weber Spirit EP-425 vs E-425 Grill
| Feature | Weber Spirit EP-425 | Weber Spirit E-425 |
| Main Burners | 4 | 4 |
| Dimensions | 25.5″D × 51.8″W × 46.3″H | 26.6″D × 51.8″W × 46.2″H |
| Sear Zone | Boost Burners (40% more power) | Boost Burners (40% more power) |
| Digital Thermometer | ✔ Built-in | ✖ Not included |
| Control Panel | Stainless steel | Cast-aluminum |
| Side Tables | Stainless steel | Porcelain-enameled steel |
| Weber Works Side Rails | ✔ | ✔ |
| Warranty | 10-year limited | 10-year limited |
| Check Price on Amazon | Buy on Amazon | Buy on Amazon |
Detailed Comparative Review
Before diving into the finer points, let me set the scene: I grilled everything from thick rib-eyes to pizzas, and even ran simultaneous meals for a family gathering. Both models faced the same weather conditions and the same hungry crowd.
Design and Build Quality
The EP-425 feels just a touch more upscale. Its stainless steel control panel has a brushed finish that resists fingerprints and wipes clean in seconds. The digital thermometer sits right on top, glowing bright enough to read across the yard after dark. The E-425 shares the same solid frame and cast-aluminum cook box, but its side tables are porcelain-enameled rather than stainless. They’re sturdy and weather-resistant, yet they don’t have quite the same polished look.
Both grills roll easily thanks to heavy-duty locking casters, and Weber’s 10-year limited warranty gives real peace of mind. If you’re judging purely on durability, it’s a draw.
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
Ease of Use
Starting either grill is a one-hand affair. Weber’s Snap-Jet ignition lit every burner on the first try—no drama, no wasted propane. The EP-425’s digital thermometer was a pleasant surprise. I could check the grill’s internal temperature from across the patio without lifting the lid, which meant fewer heat fluctuations during long cooks. On the E-425 I had to rely on a traditional lid thermometer or my own probe, which worked fine but wasn’t as seamless.
Cooking Performance
When it comes to actual grilling, these two are neck and neck. The Boost Burners create a sear zone hot enough to rival a steakhouse. I clocked preheat times of about 8 minutes to reach 600°F on both units. Heat distribution across the grates was impressively even, giving my chicken and fish consistent color with no cold spots. Porcelain-enameled, cast-iron grates locked in juices and were easy to clean with a quick brush after cooking.
I used the Weber Works rails for snap-on accessories—a bottle holder and extra tool hooks—on both grills. They fit perfectly and made it easy to keep tongs and sauces organized.
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
Everyday Experience
For quick weeknight dinners, the E-425’s simplicity actually felt refreshing. There’s nothing to set up beyond igniting the burners and grilling. On weekends, though, the EP-425’s digital thermometer became a real convenience, especially when smoking ribs or baking pizza where steady temps matter. The stainless side tables also handled hot cast-iron pans without leaving marks.
Weber Spirit EP-425 Propane Grill
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
Pros:
- Built-in digital thermometer for precise monitoring
- Stainless steel control panel and side tables look sharp and clean easily
- Same powerful Boost Sear Zone and even heat as the E-425
- Weber Works rails for accessories
Cons:
- Higher price for features some grillers may not need
- Slightly narrower depth than the E-425, though it doesn’t impact cooking
Weber Spirit E-425 Propane Grill
- This Weber Spirit Black Gas Grill features powerful Boost Burners that unleash 40% more power in the largest Sear Zone in its class; Now you can crank up the...
Pros:
- Identical grilling performance at a lower cost
- Durable porcelain-enameled grates and side tables
- Boost Burners deliver serious searing power
- Weber Works accessory compatibility
Cons:
- No digital thermometer—requires a separate probe for precise temp checks
- Porcelain side tables show scratches a bit more easily
Conclusion and Recommendation:
After plenty of cookouts, I can confirm both the EP-425 and E-425 deliver Weber’s hallmark performance: fast heat-up, steady temperatures, and that unbeatable sear. The deciding factor is how much you value convenience and finish.
If you love gadgets, frequently grill after dark, or just appreciate a premium look, the Weber Spirit EP-425 is worth the extra dollars. The digital thermometer alone saves guesswork and keeps you from lifting the lid too often.
If you’re more of a “light it and grill” cook who’s happy to use a handheld thermometer, the Weber Spirit E-425 gives you the same firepower and long-term durability for less money.
Either way, you’re getting a four-burner gas grill built to last a decade or more—a true backyard investment.
