Breville Juice Fountain Plus vs Compact Juicer: Which One Deserves a Spot on Your Countertop?

I’ve always believed that the right juicer can make or break your healthy routine. A good juicer doesn’t just squeeze fruits and veggies — it saves time, keeps the nutrients intact, and makes the whole experience enjoyable instead of messy. Over the past few months, I’ve used both the Breville Juice Fountain Plus (JE98XL) and the Breville Juice Fountain Compact (BJE200XL), and let me tell you — both are impressive in their own right, but they serve very different needs.

If you’re torn between these two Breville favorites, I’ll walk you through my personal experience with both — from how they look and perform to which one truly feels worth the counter space.

Key Difference Between Breville Juice Fountain Plus vs Compact Juicer

The main difference between the Breville Juice Fountain Plus and the Compact comes down to size, power, and capacity.

• The Plus has an 850-watt motor with a larger juice jug and pulp container, making it great for families or regular juicers.
• The Compact, on the other hand, uses a 700-watt motor and a smaller footprint, perfect for those short on counter space or who juice occasionally.

In simple terms: the Plus is the “bigger workhorse”, while the Compact is the “efficient space-saver.”

Comparison Table: Breville Juice Fountain Plus vs Compact Juicer

Features	Breville Juice Fountain Plus (JE98XL)	Breville Juice Fountain Compact (BJE200XL)
Power	850 Watts	700 Watts
Material	Heavy-Grade Polymer	Metal & Plastic
Chute Size	3 inches (Extra-Wide)	3 inches (Extra-Wide)
Juice Jug Capacity	35.2 fl oz	25 fl oz
Pulp Container	2.6 qt	1.6 qt
Speed Settings	Two Speeds	Single Speed
Weight	10.1 lbs	8.4 lbs
Dishwasher Safe	Yes	Yes
Warranty	1 Year	1 Year
Best For	Regular Juicers, Families	Compact Kitchens, Beginners
Check Latest Price & Deals	Buy on Amazon	Buy on Amazon

Design and Build Quality

The first thing I noticed when unboxing both was the difference in size and presence. The Juice Fountain Plus has that taller, professional look — with a wide base and solid polymer construction. It’s not heavy, but it definitely feels robust and substantial. The silver finish with a brushed design gives it a polished, clean aesthetic that fits in well with modern kitchens.

The Compact, as the name suggests, lives up to its reputation. It’s much smaller and feels a little lighter in hand. But don’t mistake its size for weakness — Breville managed to fit the pulp container inside the main unit’s footprint, which makes it incredibly space-efficient. It’s ideal for smaller counters or apartments where every inch matters.

While both models are well-designed, the Compact feels a little simpler, while the Plus feels more “complete” and professional.

Verdict: If you have space and juice frequently, go with the Plus. If you live in a small apartment or want something easy to move around, the Compact is a smart choice.

Power and Performance

Here’s where things start to separate.

The Juice Fountain Plus runs on an 850-watt motor with two speeds — low for soft fruits and greens, and high for tougher produce like beets or carrots. When I juiced a mix of apples, spinach, and carrots, the Plus went through everything effortlessly. The dual-speed control gave me flexibility, especially when alternating between delicate and dense ingredients.

The Compact, on the other hand, has a 700-watt motor and only one speed. It’s powerful enough to handle most fruits and veggies, but I did notice it struggled a bit with denser items like beets and kale stems. You can still get great results — it just takes slightly longer, and the pulp tends to be a little wetter.

Verdict: For raw power and versatility, the Plus clearly wins. The Compact is better suited for lighter, smaller batches of juice.

Ease of Use

Both machines are very easy to set up. Breville’s design philosophy focuses on simplicity — a few key parts, quick locks, and intuitive assembly.

The Compact shines here. It has fewer parts overall, so setup and disassembly take literally seconds. Everything fits snugly, and it’s surprisingly stable despite its smaller footprint. I found it incredibly convenient for quick morning juices before heading to work.

The Plus, meanwhile, takes just a little longer because of its larger pulp container and more parts. But it also offers that handy dual-speed dial and a bigger juice jug with a froth separator — great for larger servings.

Verdict: If convenience and quick cleanup matter most, the Compact takes the edge. If you don’t mind an extra minute or two for setup, the Plus offers more functionality.

Juice Yield and Quality

Both juicers use the same titanium-reinforced cutting disc and Italian-made micro-mesh filter, which are key to Breville’s consistent performance.

However, in my side-by-side tests, the Juice Fountain Plus extracted slightly more juice, especially from fibrous veggies. The pulp came out drier, meaning better extraction efficiency. With apples and oranges, both produced smooth, froth-free juice thanks to the froth separator, but the Plus delivered about 10–15% more yield on average.

As for taste, I didn’t notice a huge difference — both produce clean, fresh-tasting juice with minimal oxidation. But the Plus’s stronger motor helps achieve a smoother consistency for tougher produce.

Verdict: The Plus edges ahead in performance and yield, though the Compact still produces great juice for its size.

Noise Level

Neither of these models is whisper-quiet — they’re centrifugal juicers, after all. But the noise level is manageable.

The Compact is slightly louder, possibly because it’s smaller and has less insulation. The Plus produces a deeper, steadier hum that’s easier on the ears, especially on the lower speed setting.

Verdict: Both are similar, but the Plus feels more stable and less rattly during operation.

Cleaning and Maintenance

This is one area where both Breville juicers truly shine.

All the removable parts are dishwasher-safe, and both come with a handy cleaning brush for the mesh filter. The Compact takes the win for cleaning speed — with fewer parts, it’s much faster to rinse off.

The Plus takes a bit more time, but because of its larger capacity, you don’t have to clean it as often if you’re making multiple servings in one go.

Verdict: For quick daily use, the Compact is easier to clean. For bulk juicing, the Plus saves time overall.

Breville Juice Fountain Plus (JE98XL)

Pros:

• Powerful 850-watt motor for all types of produce
• Dual-speed control for better flexibility
• Larger juice and pulp containers
• Excellent juice yield and smooth texture
• Easy to use and dishwasher-safe

Cons:

• Takes more counter space
• Slightly heavier
• A bit more cleanup time due to size

Buy on Amazon

Breville Juice Fountain Compact (BJE200XL)

Pros:

• Compact, space-saving design
• Quick setup and cleanup
• Ideal for small kitchens and single servings
• Affordable without compromising quality
• Same cutting disc and mesh system as higher models

Cons:

• Only one speed setting
• Smaller juice jug and pulp bin
• Not ideal for heavy-duty or frequent juicing

Buy on Amazon

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?

After using both extensively, I’d say it depends on how you juice.

If you juice daily, love experimenting with fruits and vegetables, or make juice for the family — the Breville Juice Fountain Plus is the clear winner. It’s stronger, faster, and more versatile. The extra power and dual speeds make a noticeable difference when working with harder produce. It feels like a step closer to professional performance.

But if you’re someone who juices occasionally, prefers small batches, or has a limited kitchen space, the Breville Juice Fountain Compact is a fantastic pick. It’s light, affordable, and perfect for quick, no-fuss juicing sessions.

My Recommendation: Breville Juice Fountain Plus (JE98XL)

If I had to keep just one on my counter, it would be the Juice Fountain Plus. It’s more powerful, extracts slightly more juice, and offers better control. It’s simply more capable — without being overly complicated.

That said, the Compact still earns full marks for practicality. Think of it as the “smart little brother” that does 80% of what the Plus does — just in a smaller, cuter package.