If you’ve ever used a Breville juicer, you probably already know the brand’s reputation for quality and performance. But when you have two popular models like the Breville Juice Fountain Plus (JE98XL) and the Breville Juice Fountain Cold (BJE430SIL) sitting side by side, deciding which one deserves a spot on your countertop can be tricky.
I’ve been using both for a few weeks now — testing them with everything from apples and carrots to leafy greens and citrus. On paper, they share a lot: both have 850-watt motors, wide 3-inch feed chutes, and stainless-steel cutting systems. But after daily use, I noticed that their personalities are slightly different.
Here’s my hands-on breakdown to help you decide which Breville juicer actually fits your style and needs.
Key Difference Between Breville Juice Fountain Plus vs Breville Juice Fountain Cold
The Breville Juice Fountain Plus is a classic centrifugal juicer that focuses on speed and simplicity. It’s designed to deliver juice fast, with dual-speed control and straightforward operation — perfect for anyone just stepping into the world of juicing.
The Breville Juice Fountain Cold, however, brings in newer technology — namely Cold Spin Technology, which reduces heat transfer during extraction. This means the juice retains more nutrients and can stay fresh for longer in the refrigerator. It also has a larger juice jug (70 fl oz) and some extra convenience features like a juice nozzle and LED overload protection.
In short:
- The Plus is the practical performer.
- The Cold is the modern upgrade, made for those who juice in batches and care about maximum nutrient retention.
- The Breville Juice Fountain Plus is the perfect way to get yourself into the world of juicing; This centrifugal juicer features a 3 inch extra wide fruit chute,...
- The Breville Juice Fountain Cold is a high performance juicer with an innovative cold extraction system that can provide a super sized 70fl oz of juice...
Comparison Table: Breville Juice Fountain Plus vs Breville Juice Fountain Cold
| Feature | Breville Juice Fountain Plus (JE98XL) | Breville Juice Fountain Cold (BJE430SIL) |
| Motor Power | 850 Watts | 850 Watts |
| Feed Chute | 3 Inches | 3 Inches |
| Technology | Standard Centrifugal Extraction | Cold Spin Technology |
| Jug Capacity | 35.2 fl oz | 70 fl oz |
| Pulp Bin | 2.6 qt | 3.6 qt |
| Material | Heavy Grade Polymer | Plastic with Stainless Finish |
| Dimensions | 14.09”D x 12.6”W x 16.42”H | 7.99”D x 13.62”W x 16.65”H |
| Special Features | Built-in Froth Separator, Dual Speed | Cold Extraction System, LED Display, Seal & Store Jug |
| Weight | 10.1 lbs | 10.96 lbs |
| Warranty | 1 Year | 1 Year |
| Best For | Quick daily juicing | Batch juicing and longer freshness |
| Check Latest Price & Deals | Buy on Amazon | Buy on Amazon |
Design and Build Quality
Both juicers reflect Breville’s signature design language — sleek, modern, and functional. But their finishes make them stand apart.
The Juice Fountain Plus has a painted silver polymer body with a sturdy build. It’s lighter and slightly more compact, making it easier to move or store. The control dial sits front and center, offering just two speeds — simple, intuitive, and ideal for everyday use.
The Juice Fountain Cold feels more refined. It’s a little taller and heavier, with a stainless-silver finish that looks premium. The larger juice jug and the detachable spout for direct glass juicing are thoughtful touches that make it feel more “complete.”
If your kitchen already features stainless appliances, the Cold version blends in beautifully. But the Plus still has that Breville charm — minimal yet efficient.
- The Breville Juice Fountain Plus is the perfect way to get yourself into the world of juicing; This centrifugal juicer features a 3 inch extra wide fruit chute,...
- The Breville Juice Fountain Cold is a high performance juicer with an innovative cold extraction system that can provide a super sized 70fl oz of juice...
Ease of Use
This is where both models shine equally. Breville clearly designs its juicers for convenience, and both feature the 3-inch wide chute that allows you to juice whole fruits and large vegetables without pre-cutting.
That said, I found the Fountain Plus slightly faster to set up and operate. It’s straightforward — plug it in, drop your produce, and watch it work.
The Fountain Cold, on the other hand, gives you more control and peace of mind. The LED display lights up if the motor ever overheats or overloads — something I really appreciated while juicing large batches of dense vegetables like beets.
If you’re all about quick morning juicing, the Plus might feel more effortless. But if you’re juicing for the family or storing juice for the next few days, the Cold model wins on convenience.
- The Breville Juice Fountain Plus is the perfect way to get yourself into the world of juicing; This centrifugal juicer features a 3 inch extra wide fruit chute,...
Performance and Juice Quality
Here’s where the Cold Spin Technology in the Breville Juice Fountain Cold actually makes a difference.
When juicing the same batch of apples, kale, and carrots, I noticed the juice from the Cold model stayed cooler to the touch and maintained color and flavor slightly better after being refrigerated for a few hours.
The Juice Fountain Plus, on the other hand, works incredibly fast — you’ll have a full jug in seconds — but the juice tends to foam more, and it’s best consumed immediately for the freshest taste.
So, while both deliver smooth and pulp-free juice, the Cold model’s nutrient retention and storage advantage make it the better pick if you like prepping ahead.
- The Breville Juice Fountain Cold is a high performance juicer with an innovative cold extraction system that can provide a super sized 70fl oz of juice...
Cleaning and Maintenance
Cleaning centrifugal juicers can be a chore, but Breville has done a great job minimizing the effort. Both models have dishwasher-safe parts and come with a cleaning brush for the mesh filter.
The Fountain Plus has fewer detachable parts, making cleanup slightly quicker, but the Fountain Cold’s components feel sturdier and easier to rinse, especially the larger pulp bin and juice jug.
Both have well-designed spouts and froth separators, so you won’t end up with messy drips on your countertop. I also liked the invertible nozzle on the Cold model — it’s a small but brilliant feature that keeps the counter spotless between pours.
- The Breville Juice Fountain Plus is the perfect way to get yourself into the world of juicing; This centrifugal juicer features a 3 inch extra wide fruit chute,...
Noise Level and Operation
Centrifugal juicers are never whisper-quiet, but these two models are surprisingly manageable. The Fountain Plus has a more traditional motor hum, while the Fountain Cold feels a bit smoother and slightly quieter during operation.
Both stay stable on the counter, even when processing hard produce like carrots or beets. The dual-speed control helps — you can switch to the lower setting for softer fruits to reduce splatter and noise.
Capacity and Storage
This is one of the biggest deciding factors between the two.
The Fountain Plus comes with a 35.2 fl oz jug, perfect for one or two servings. Meanwhile, the Fountain Cold doubles that with a massive 70 fl oz jug — ideal for families or those who like to prep juice for several days.
The Cold’s Seal & Store Jug lets you refrigerate juice for up to 72 hours without significant nutrient loss. That alone makes it a game-changer for people who batch juice once and drink throughout the week.
Breville Juice Fountain Plus (JE98XL)
- The Breville Juice Fountain Plus is the perfect way to get yourself into the world of juicing; This centrifugal juicer features a 3 inch extra wide fruit chute,...
Pros:
- Affordable entry into premium juicing
- Dual-speed control for versatility
- Built-in froth separator
- Fast and efficient for everyday use
- Compact and easy to assemble
Cons:
- Smaller juice jug
- More foam during extraction
- Juice best consumed immediately
Breville Juice Fountain Cold (BJE430SIL)
- The Breville Juice Fountain Cold is a high performance juicer with an innovative cold extraction system that can provide a super sized 70fl oz of juice...
Pros:
- Cold Spin Technology preserves nutrients
- Extra-large 70 oz jug for batch juicing
- LED overload protection
- Juice nozzle prevents drips
- Slightly quieter and more polished design
Cons:
- Larger footprint on the counter
- Pricier than the Plus model
- Slightly longer cleaning time due to more components
Final Verdict — Which Breville Juicer Wins?
After using both extensively, I’d say your choice depends entirely on how you juice.
If you’re a casual juicer who makes one or two glasses at a time and prefers quick cleanup, the Breville Juice Fountain Plus is the perfect fit. It’s powerful, efficient, and delivers consistently smooth juice — no complications, no fuss.
However, if you’re serious about juicing — maybe preparing batches for the whole family or storing fresh juice for later — the Breville Juice Fountain Cold is the better investment. The Cold Spin Technology, larger capacity, and longer freshness make it ideal for anyone committed to juicing as part of their daily routine.
Personally, I lean toward the Fountain Cold. It feels more refined, cleaner to use, and the ability to juice in bulk without sacrificing quality is a big win.
Both are excellent machines from Breville, but the difference is simple:
- The Juice Fountain Plus is about speed.
- The Juice Fountain Cold is about sustainability and freshness.
Either way, you can’t go wrong — both will turn your produce into fresh, nutrient-rich juice in seconds.
