Cuisinart Griddler Deluxe vs Breville Panini Press: A Hands-On Kitchen Test

Some appliances instantly prove their worth the moment you start cooking. Over the last few weeks, I rotated two popular countertop grills through my busy kitchen—the Cuisinart GR-150P1 Deluxe Griddler and the Breville BSG520XL Panini Duo. From quick weekday lunches to weekend brunch spreads, I grilled, pressed, and seared everything from thick Italian paninis to delicate breakfast quesadillas to see which machine deserves the prime spot on my counter.

Both are stainless steel standouts, but their personalities couldn’t be more different. The Cuisinart aims to be a full-service indoor grill with six cooking modes, while the Breville focuses on perfect sandwiches with a smaller footprint. After dozens of meals and plenty of cleanup, here’s how they compare.

Key Difference Between Cuisinart Griddler Deluxe vs Breville Panini Press

The Cuisinart Griddler is a multi-function powerhouse—think of it as a portable stovetop and grill in one, capable of searing steaks, flipping pancakes, or melting a triple-stack panini. The Breville Panini Press, on the other hand, is a specialist: it’s all about making flawlessly crisp sandwiches and quick flat-top snacks with minimal fuss.

Quick Comparison Table: Cuisinart Griddler Deluxe vs Breville Panini Press

Feature	Cuisinart GR-150P1 Deluxe Griddler	Breville BSG520XL Panini Duo
Power	1800 watts	1500 watts
Cooking Surface	240 sq in (open)	2-slice flat plates
Temperature Range	Dual-zone, up to 500 °F sear	Fixed temp with adjustable height
Cooking Modes	Contact grill, panini press, full grill, full griddle, half grill/half griddle, top melt	Panini press, open-face melts, flat grill
Plates	Removable, reversible, nonstick	Fixed flat nonstick
Weight	13.3 lbs	8 lbs
Cleaning	Dishwasher-safe plates & drip tray	Wipe-clean plates, integrated cord wrap
Check Price & Deals	Buy on Amazon	Buy on Amazon

Detailed Hands-On Comparison

Design & Build

The Cuisinart Griddler feels like a serious piece of equipment. Brushed stainless steel housing, a sturdy handlebar, and a locking top cover give it a premium, almost commercial vibe. Its reversible grill/griddle plates slide in and out easily and stay solid after repeated swaps.

The Breville Panini Duo is more compact and lighter, perfect for small kitchens or quick counter moves. Its flat top and bottom plates create a sleek silhouette, and the rear foot lets you store it upright. Both have excellent stainless finishes, but the Cuisinart’s larger footprint demands more space.

Ease of Use

If you like control, the Griddler is your dream machine. Dual-zone temperature knobs let you run the top plate hotter than the bottom, or vice versa. Sear mode hits 500 °F for that steakhouse crust. I appreciated the clear LED lights signaling preheat and ready status, and the adjustable lid means tall sandwiches don’t get squashed.

The Breville is simplicity defined. Plug it in, let it heat, and start pressing. The floating hinge maintains even pressure no matter how thick your bread. Adjustable height control is a nice touch for open-face melts. There’s no temperature dial—one consistent heat setting does it all, and for classic grilled cheese or paninis, it’s nearly foolproof.

Cooking Performance

I threw everything at these grills. The Cuisinart seared ribeye steaks to a gorgeous crust in under 10 minutes and handled breakfast pancakes without a hitch. Dual-zone control meant I could griddle eggs gently while searing bacon crisp—something the Breville simply can’t match.

The Breville, however, nails sandwiches. Thick ciabatta with layers of mozzarella and tomato came out evenly browned edge to edge, with perfect grill marks from its flat plate design. For pure panini artistry, it edges out the Cuisinart, which sometimes leaves slightly softer centers on very thick bread unless you crank the sear.

Versatility

This category is no contest. The Cuisinart’s six functions—contact grill, full grill, full griddle, half-and-half, panini press, and top melt—make it a true all-in-one. You can cook an entire brunch on it or press a dozen paninis at once by opening it flat for a 240-square-inch surface.

The Breville is designed for one thing: sandwiches and quick snacks. You can toast quesadillas or reheat pizza slices, but it’s not meant for pancakes or steaks.

Cleanup & Maintenance

The Griddler’s removable, reversible plates and integrated drip tray slide straight into the dishwasher—huge win for weeknight cleanup. After a steak session, a quick scrape and a dishwasher run had it looking new.

The Breville’s fixed plates clean up with a simple wipe thanks to a slick nonstick surface. There’s no drip tray, but because you’re rarely cooking fatty meats, mess is minimal. For small jobs, it’s effortless.

Cuisinart GR-150P1 Deluxe Griddler

Pros:

• Six cooking modes and massive 240 sq in surface
• Dual-zone temperature control and 500 °F sear
• Reversible, removable dishwasher-safe plates
• Adjustable top melt feature

Cons:

• Larger and heavier—needs more counter space
• More knobs and options may intimidate beginners

Buy on Amazon

Breville BSG520XL Panini Duo Non Stick Sandwich Maker

Pros:

• Compact and lightweight; easy to store upright
• Even, fast heating with floating hinge
• Ideal for perfect paninis and open-face melts
• Simple operation—no settings to fiddle with

Cons:

• Limited versatility—primarily a sandwich press
• Fixed plates mean no dishwasher cleanup

Buy on Amazon

My Verdict & Recommendation:

After weeks of real cooking, here’s where I land:

• Choose the Cuisinart Griddler if you want an indoor grill that replaces multiple appliances. It can handle breakfast spreads, steak dinners, and, yes, paninis, all with impressive heat control and dishwasher-safe convenience.
• Pick the Breville Panini Press if your main goal is café-quality sandwiches with zero learning curve. It’s compact, quick to heat, and produces consistent results every time.

Personally, I’m keeping the Cuisinart Griddler on my counter. Its flexibility means I can cook almost anything without firing up the stove, and the reversible plates make cleanup painless. But when I’m craving a simple late-night grilled cheese, the Breville’s grab-and-go design is tough to beat.

Both appliances excel at what they promise—your choice depends on whether you need a culinary multitasker or the ultimate sandwich specialist.